Review: The Coffee Trader by David Liss

Book info:

Paperback: 432 pages
Publisher: Ballantine Books (February 3, 2004)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0375760903

ISBN-13: 978-0375760907
Genre: historical fiction
Target group: adults


The book is set in 1659 in Amsterdam – one generation before The Conspiracy of Paper. The narration is presented from two POVs – that of once-prosperous trader, Miguel Lienzo, and a far more shadowy character, an usurer called Alonzo Alferonda. Both men are Jews who fled Portugal and Inquisition. In fact Miguel had saved Alonzo’s life, alerting his family of the danger.

After some disastrous Exchange transactions involving Brazilian sugar, debt-ridden Miguel is currently living in the basement of his more prosperous younger brother’s house. He hates every minute of it and he is fervently looking for ways to reverse his bad fortune. One night, it seems by a stroke of sheer luck, Miguel meets an attractive and enterprising Dutch widow, Geertruid Damhuis who helps him exposing some con men. After a while she suggests to her new friend a secret business partnership – she dreams of  monopolizing the market of coffee, predicting that soon enough coffee beans, currently an unfamiliar product prescribed only by apothecaries, will become hot commodity around the Europe, especially among business people. Miguel, knowing how the Stock Exchange works, is the mastermind of the plan and Geertruid is to provide financial back-up. However, are they truly open and honest with each other?

It becomes obvious pretty quickly that “coffee is a drink that brings out great passions in men, and you may be unlocking great forces if you trifle with it.” Miguel is hardly the only trader interested in its hidden potential. A far more powerful man, Solomon Parido, who sits on the local Jewish regulatory council (Ma’amad) and enjoys an opinion of a very clever merchant, seeks to thwart Miguel’s plans at all cost. He does it for profit but also for personal reasons. Some time ago Miguel had been betrothed to Parido’s daughter, until an unfortunate lack of discretion (involving a secret meeting with a pretty maid in a rather cramped closet AND the ensuing discovery) caused the relationship to end, earning him Parido’s lasting enmity. If Lienzo fails, he will not only be ruined but exiled as well…and nothing would please Parido more.

 Parido’s dirty tricks make Miguel turn to Alferonda, now an excommunicated loanshark, a man feared and hated by every thief and debtor. As the narration twists and turns Miguel starts to distrust everyone, being more and more entangled in slightly paranoid world of business and deceit. Not only he must face the constant threats of his creditors along with the scrutiny and possible punitive measures from the draconian Jewish council but also he finds himself more and more attracted to his put-upon, pregnant sister-in-law who has been fancing him for some time as well.

What I liked:

It is my second David Liss novel and I’m  admiring this writer more and more. Liss meticulously recreates the 17th century Dutch city of Amsterdam fully based on historical documents – really it seems that the author completed exhaustive research if you only consult the list of his sources, provided at the beginning of the book. He brings Lienzo’s world to life in great detail, as well as the workings of the bourse which are indeed very similar to modern commodities markets (but fortunately there is no trade of whale oil anymore – shudder, poor whales).

The complex storyline, chock full of intrigue, is really compelling but, what’s even more praiseworthy, the author didn’t repeat the scheme from his first, very successful book – no murder mystery here, only coffee, business and some romance as well. The characters are as three-dimensional as I like: Miguel, actually, is a surprisingly nuanced figure but also Alonzo the usurer and Hannah, the wife of Miguel’s brother, Daniel, contribute greatly to the story showing how Jewish immigrants were treated by Dutch people and their compatriots as well. It seems that being Jewish in Amsterdam during the Golden Age was extremely difficult for more than one reason. For instance, Miguel must be careful not to scorn the Ma’amad, the restrictive and mysterious governing body of the Jewish community. He must also be wary not to conduct business with the Gentiles, something extremely forbidden during the mid-1650s. Hannah has to wear demure black clothes and she cannot go out without her head veiled although Dutch women, married or not, parade along undisturbed in provocative, bejewelled caps and colourful dresses. Her husband doesn’t want her to learn how to read and write although  Jewesses coming from the East are allowed to do so.

I was also delighted by the fact that the author didn’t avoid tensions inside the Jewish community itself, between Jews coming from the Southern and Eastern Europe. In short all events are portrayed quite realistically. In fact, a couple of secondary characters suffer badly from unintended consequences of Miguel’s shadowy actions – it adds a subtle but gritty moral note which plenty of other historical novels lack. I even cherished the fact that for most of the time Miguel doesn’t exactly know who to trust. In some ways his uncomfortable position emulates very well the risks that investors take today in dealing with high finance (but bear with me – no matter how boring it might sound to you I studied economics after all).

Finally there’s also something very readable about the prose style. Although the plot is hardly easy to follow you simply don’t want to put this book down until the very end. Two POVs (well, in fact even threes if you count some short glimpses of Hannah’s world) make it even more interesting.

What I didn’t like:

I wouldn’t call it a serious drawback but I have to mention it – the main character, Miguel Lienzo. A well-rounded, real-life hero, I admit it, but not exactly very likeable. Let’s face it – as a protagonist he has very few redeeming qualities – he is charming and handsome and well…ambitious…

I fully understand him being an embodiment of a businessman of any age – a man who would lie, steal, cheat, plot, deceive, gamble and hoodwink if only it might bring him some profit – but, in the end, you are not exactly sure whether you want him to succeed or not. How can you fully sympathize with somebody who, even if only for a moment or two, seriously considered killing his own brother (no matter how obnoxious) in order to run away with his pregnant sister-in-law and yet, at the same time, never wasted any occasion to screw (there is no nicer word for it) any pretty young maid in his proximity or to visit a whore? I know, I am speaking from a rather female point of view…I bet plenty of guys would find nothing wrong with this perfectly realistic behaviour but still I can’t easily condone it.

By the way I wonder whether we really deal here with the uncle of Benjamin from The Conspiracy of Paper – the same surname but I am not completely sure as other facts don’t exactly match.

Final verdict:

Overall a very intelligent reading. If you are a coffee fanatic like myself and you like good historical fiction with a dash of finance and trade then by all means go out and get yourself a copy of The Coffee Trader. Just don’t forget to brew or buy yourself some coffee too – believe me, you will crave it even more. If people at Starbucks knew their business they would sell this book along with their drinks.

This entry was posted in book review, historical and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Review: The Coffee Trader by David Liss

  1. I have wanted to try something by this author for a while. Sounds like this one might be a good choice. thanks so much for the insightful review.

  2. Blodeuedd says:

    I think I must go all perhaps not like you do when I review a truly fluffy and pink book. Lol, yes not for me

  3. Starbucks never carried 'How Starbucks Saved My Life' either. Sounds like a good book. Sometimes historical fiction works better when the main character is not famous.

  4. anachronist says:

    Diane you are very welcome!Blodeuedd if a book is not for you it IS NOT for you, period. No need to beat about the bush so thanks for an honest comment! ;)The Red Witch I totally agree.

  5. Tracy says:

    Reading both of your reviews, I think Liss' other book, A Conspiracy of Paper, would interest me more – I'd have to read the first couple of pages of this one to see if it grabbed me.

  6. anachronist says:

    I agree Tracy – although I liked this one very much the first one was truly memorable and unique.

  7. Aw… so sorry you just seem to hate this writer… 😉

  8. I truly wish I read more intelligent literature. This one sounds so intriguing…I'm just so petty when it comes to my books haha great review! 🙂

  9. anachronist says:

    Melissa (Books and Things) – right, I can't get enough of him this season! Out of pure hatred of course, but what do you want, it is such a powerful feeling!Melissa I didn't notice your pettiness last time I looked…thanks for stopping by!

  10. Karen K. says:

    I really should read David Liss since lives here in San Antonio and I've actually met his wife! Our daughters are classmates and I'm hoping to actually meet him someday. It would be embarrassing if I'd never read any of his books. I do have a copy of The Conspiracy of Paper and I should try and read it soon.

  11. anachronist says:

    Karen you are so fortunate – his books are really good and I am sure you will enjoy them! Thanks for a visit!

Comments are closed.